Category: Grain

Futures and FX going against us

This week we saw the USDA release their July World Agricultural Supply and Demand estimates, the market has reacted to this news. In this update, we take a short look at Chicago futures & the dollar.

The last two sessions in the wheat market have been in the red (figure 1). The market has been on a skyward journey over the past two weeks, however it came to an end when the USDA report came out. The WASDE report was bearish with world stocks up 1.62mmt.

This bearish report, alongside welcome rains in the US has spooked the speculators in the market. However, the SRW futures falling should not be much of a surprise, as the world issues are largely around quality not quantity. It must be noted that we typically expect any falls in production to have a 2-month lag before appearing in the WASDE report. Therefore, the August report might provide some fireworks.

To add insult to injury, the AUD has reached four-month highs (figure 2), barrelling above 77¢. This makes our wheat more expensive to export. The AUD has gained value after better than expected Chinese trade data, and remarks from the US Fed Reserve that interest rates in the US may not be as soon or as frequent as expected.

Next Week/ What does it mean?

The commitment of trader’s report will give an indication into how the speculators in the market are positioned, and we would expect them to have reduced their long positions.

There will be another weekly crop report released, and we would expect the spring crop ratings to be reduced. Although at this time of year, a large degree of quality risk will already be priced in.

Newton’s Apple

In the late 1600’s Sir Isaac Newton, developed the theory of gravity. It seems that in addition to determining that apples will fall from trees, it seems that what goes up in the grain market also comes down. After a sustained rally over recent weeks, some of the gains have been lost, however there are still good opportunities.

The wheat market has had a stellar performance, with the SRW contracts rising an average of 87¢/bu since the start of last week (across the 6 nearby contracts). The market however lost around a 20¢ (figure 1) overnight. The market had become quite overbought in recent days, and it seems that speculators in the market have started to take some of their profits.

In figure 2, the three main US futures (spot) contracts are displayed. In this chart we can see that the rally for most of June was largely in MGEX spring wheat futures, before some flows into SRW. The reality is that the worst weather issues are currently around the high protein wheat (mgex), which globally is likely to be in demand, however we still sit on ample low protein wheat.

Although the market has fallen, it is still at an attractive level compared to the period since harvest. There are ample opportunities, for the grower looking further forward. As discussed in the analysis piece “Should we lock a far forward swap”, the high carry in the market place allows us to lock in close to a $300mt swap for 16 months time.

In reality, we do not know what will happen between now and then, there could be massive or miniscule harvests in 2018. However, starting the 2018/19 season at those levels traditionally would be attractive.

Next Week

The USDA will release their WASDE report in the middle of the week, which will likely see a reduction in crops in US, Australia and Western Europe. However, to what extent is the question, and what difference will that make to overall stocks.

The US crop condition will likely also show a reduction in crop condition, but with harvest in full swing it is likely with a negative result expected that this is priced in.

A rocket to the moon, or even beyond the Kuiper belt?

Well this is good news, wheat is on a journey to the moon, and at this rate beyond the planets. The downtrend of the past week has been reversed in dramatic fashion, is this a sign of things to come?

It’s the middle of the weather market, and as we have mentioned for months this is where opportunities can arise when the trade gets jittery. Overnight we saw futures close up across the board, with US futures up 5%, and Matif following up 2%.

The market has rallied on the back of continuing bullish data being release to the market, with the US drought monitor showing large parts of the Great Plains being in a rainfall deficit, and a corresponding drop in the crop potential. In Canada, canola planting according to Statscan have exceeded wheat, as a result of more attractive gross margins on the oilseed.

In figure 1, we can see the rise in nearby Chicago SRW futures, the rise was so high that I had to change my scale this morning to fit it on the chart. The spot contract has not been at this level since mid-June last year, before it fell as production became sure. As we go through the next month, how will the weather impact on the crop?

The rise in SRW has been fantastic, and most welcome to farmers around the world. However, it is dwarfed by the Minneapolis spring wheat contract which has been a stratospheric rise the like of which has been seen for a long time. In figure 2, we can see the SRW, HRW & Mgex contract converted into A$/mt since the start of the year.

The spread between SRW and HRW/MGEX is shown in figure 3, and it currently sits A$124 above spot SRW. This is due to the expected shortage of hi-pro wheat, will this rise be sustainable and make it past the moon, and beyond the Kuiper belt or will it crash back down to earth?

Next Week

The USDA will release their quarterly grain stock reports, will this show a downturn in US stocks or has less been used than expected. This report has traditionally had the capacity to move the markets markedly.

All strategies must evolve to take into account the potential average-low production environment in the coming season. There is no point removing price risk in order to replace it with production risk.

Turnaround Thursday (at least partially)

There has been a slight turnaround in the market, but overall prices are substantially more attractive than they have been in the post-harvest period. In this week’s commentary, we examine the potential impact of crude oil on Australian wheat, and why we should be aware of it.

There has been a welcome (for sellers) rally in the wheat futures over the past fortnight (figure 1), as a result of weather woes in the US. Overnight however the market performed a partial flip and dropped around 2%. The trade will be watching the weather with close eyes, especially as Russian crops look to again be in good condition. This factor, combined with a depreciating rouble (more on that later), is likely be putting some caps on futures for the next few days.

At a local level, there are still major concerns about the coming harvest which has led to a substantial rise in pricing. This has especially been seen with continuing strengthening in basis in Adelaide & Port Lincoln (figure 2).

In addition to supply concerns for the coming season, the growers are not surprisingly reluctant sellers. This has led to the market paying up to acquire some cover, however we need to be aware that if the concerns start to be alleviated, then the interest from the trade may diminish. There is still a long way to go until harvest, and we shouldn’t write off the crop at the end of June.

As we all know, foreign exchange plays a factor in commodity trading. The Russian economy is largely dependent on oil revenues, and is also a major competitor for Australian wheat. In figure 3, we have charted the Rouble against the US$, and the price of crude oil since early 2014. This period has seen a reduction in crude oil prices, which has led to a weakening of the Rouble, the correlation between the two is almost perfect at -0.96.

The oil price in recent weeks has started to slide again, and the market remains bearish which has resulted in a further deterioration in the Rouble. If the fall in oil continues, then by proxy Russian wheat will become more competitive on the market.

Next Week

Like a broken record, the trade will largely be concerned with weather events in the northern hemisphere. As the days flow, any weather risk premium in the market will lessen unless we see some major production failures.

We still have to keep into account that even when excluding Chinese wheat stocks, the world still has considerable supplies.

Knife edge market

This time of year, has typically been one of great volatility as the northern hemisphere commences harvest. This can easily be seen in the current market, where the weather is the major driver. The market stays on a knife edge, where every new piece of information is propelling the market.

The past week has been quite exciting in the grain market. The USDA release weekly crop condition reports, which has shown the lowest good/excellent condition since 2006 at 45%. This in combination with continued poor weather across the US has led to all futures contracts experiencing strong rallies of around 2-4% (figure 1).

The fear in the marketplace is largely centred around high protein wheats, due to deteriorating crop condition of spring wheat. This can be seen clearly in the ascent of the spread between the CME soft red winter wheat (SRW) and MGEX hard red winter wheat (HRW). The HRW contract is high protein with protein specs of 13%. In the past two months, the spread has increased dramatically (figure 2) to 180¢/bu on the spot contract. If there is a shortage of protein around the world, this could be some stronger local premiums for export protein.

In the past week, the WASDE and ABARES crop reports were released, however had little in the way of surprises. They do however each contain positive insights, and are discussed in more details on the following links:

Global wheat stocks have fallen and risen
The average ABARES

At a local level, the dry weather continues to paint a bleak picture for much of the country especially SA/WA. This has resulted in continued strength of APW basis levels in Adelaide & Port Lincoln (figure 3), which since harvest have remained quite stagnant.

Next Week

The US crop condition report is released this weekend. I wouldn’t be surprised to see spring crop conditions deteriorate further.

The recent rally has provided some good pricing opportunities to capture some strong basis around the country. It is worthwhile to consider your marketing options, one of which could be the sale of physical and the purchase of call options to continue to have exposure to the futures market.

The rain in Spain doesn’t stay mainly on the plains

In our grain article yesterday, we picked out a few bullish factors at play in the market. Our view is that based on current market factors that pricing is close to the floor. In this weekly comment, we look at current pricing and the situation in Spain.

This week was a short week with the American markets closed due to the Memorial Day public holiday. The futures market closed red three days this week, with a gradual slide down 8¢/bu (Fig 1) from last Friday. Interestingly, in the past week we have seen a strong rise in basis (Fig 2). This week, we finally see Port Lincoln achieving positive basis since early December. A welcome sign, for farmers on the EP who are struggling with poor season starting conditions.

In the past week, we have also seen the Baltic Dry Index (BDI) fall below the 200-day moving average (Fig 3). The BDI is considered a leading economic indicator as the cargoes typically transported by bulk vessels are commodities requiring further processing (iron ore, coal, grains etc) to create an end product, thereby giving an insight into future economic performance. The poor economic data in China, and declining Iron Ore returns could place further pressure on the A$.

If you have seen My Fairy Lady, you may recall that “the rain in Spain stays mainly in the plain”, well not this year.  Forecasts this week are predicting barley yields falling by 15%, and wheat by 15%. This will result in an increase in imports. In figure 4, we can see that the north of Spain is most heavily impacted, which is where the majority of the crop is grown. Although Spain is most heavily impacted, we are also seeing worrying dry patches appear in other areas of Europe, namely in eastern France & west Germany.

Next Week

The US non-farm payroll is released tomorrow, which could have an impact on the continued strength of the USD.

The main focus continues to be on the heavens. We are well into the weather market, and issues arising overseas and unfortunately locally will impact on pricing. There may prove to be pricing spikes in the coming weeks which will prove good selling opportunities especially for old crop grain.

A bullish downgrade?

The grain market continues to consolidate over the past week, after the large rise early in the month on the back of the Kansas snow event. There are some small glimmers of hope which are starting to crack through the bearish wall, and lend some support to prices.

Firstly, let’s have a look at futures. Late last week we saw a 10¢/bu rise (fig 1), however as we moved through the week half the gains were lost. At a local level basis around country moved very little (fig 2), and in the past week there was little grower selling as most farmers are pre-occupied with seeding. All in all, not very exciting in pricing.

At the moment, we think that we are close to the floor of the market and downside is quite limited. There are a number of weather woes around the world with the possibility of drought across the parts of the northern plains of the US. Locally it is increasingly looking like conditions will be dry over the next three months.

The BOM released their climate outlook summary which points towards a drier SA & WA (see map), which has already been experiencing dry conditions with many dry seeding. After having spoken to a number of farmers and consultants, it seems that the EP is in the worst condition and needs rain soon to get things going.

The International Grain Council released their monthly crop forecasts, reducing global end stocks for 2017/18 down 2mmt. This is largely insignificant; however, corn was reduced by 34mmt on the back of increased demand, which will help with sorghum and barley pricing if forecasts are accurate.

What does it mean

The main focus for farmers this week will be keeping an eye on the heavens. We are well into the weather market and although global stocks are still exceptionally high there are still the opportunities for spikes in pricing.

It’s Un-Real

In this week’s comment we look at a surprise corruption investigation into the Brazilian president, which has caused shockwaves throughout the country, devaluing the Brazilian Real and impacting agricultural commodities.

This week the wheat market was largely quiet (figure 1) with a lack of fresh news, there are still continuing concerns in Kansas, however the worries have switched from snow to excess waterlogging. In the coming weeks, we will start to gain more clarity. At a local level basis levels were fairly static with the exception of small increases in Port Lincoln and Kwinana (figure 2). Particularly in Port Lincoln, where there are concerns about lack of moisture for seeding, and with it looking increasingly likely they will miss any falls this weekend.

They just can’t get a break in Brazil, with a high number of politicians involved with bribes including with large-scale meat packer JBS. The scandal has reached the top tier of the government with President Michel Temer being placed under investigation for alleged payments of to keep witnesses quiet. All in all, it’s a messy situation which has impacted the Real (figure 3) which plummeted against the US dollar a whopping 7%.

Currency plays a part in determining which countries are more attractive for exports. Brazil is a major exporter of soybeans and cattle, and exports will shift to Brazil. It is always important to keep an eye on the other major exporters as we have seen major volatility in the past due to political uncertainty.

Due to the falling currency, there is now increased demand for Brazilian soybeans which has led to US soybean futures falling (figure 4) with exports likely to switch origin. Over-night they fell a dramatic US$11/mt, wiping out all gains in the past month.

What does this mean?

Overnight the commitment of traders report will be released, which will give an insight into whether the speculators are bullish or bearish on the market.

Locally interest will be towards the rainfall expected across much of the country, to determine how beneficial it has been.

Canola where the action is

This week’s new season World Agricultural Supply and Demand Estimates (WASDE) were somewhat of a letdown, in terms of impact in prices.  We have however seen some movement in local markets, notably for new crop canola and old crop wheat.

Old crop canola prices have been frustratingly sticky, for those who are still holding onto inventory.  The market is stuck around the $520-525 port level, or $540 delivered Melbourne.  This is a slight discount on harvest, so not much has been gained or lost through holding Canola.

Figure 1 shows that new crop Canola has had a nice little rally in recent weeks. Concerns surrounding sowing weather in Canada has given ICE Canola a lift.  The AUD has lost 5.5% relative to the Euro in the last month, which along with a small rise in MATIF Rapeseed, has seen the European contract add $40/t in our terms.

Local Canola prices for 17/18 have lifted in line with futures, with bids this week around the $530/t port level.  Interestingly, basis on these forwards to both ICE and MATIF are currently much stronger than at the last harvest.  However, they remain below the levels of the three years previous.

Since Anzac Day delivered wheat and barley prices have gained some ground. With growers busy on seeders, no one is driving the trucks so this market has tightened somewhat.  SFW wheat has hit $218/t delivered Melbourne, while F1 Barley is up to $200. These prices are 10-20% better than harvest, and are worth considering.

The week ahead

The WASDE report this week was largely in line with expectations, but it did predict a decline in world oilseed stocks this year, which might provide impetus for Canola markets if there are some production problems.

For local delivered markets this might be a sweet spot for selling.  There is likely to be a bit of supply come on once sowing is finished, and especially in the new financial year, so locking some pricing in now might be a good idea.

Kansas: The Phantom Menace

An interesting but frustrating week in the grain trade. At the start of the week newswires and social media were inundated with reports of general grievous damage to Kansas wheat crops caused by the force of snow and frost. In this week’s comment, we look at how the market responded locally and globally, and my views on being cautious in regards to the Kansas wheat tour results.

The background to the issues at the early part of this week are explained in Tuesdays analysis piece “It’s snow joking matter”, but in summary the speculators had a record net short, and the reports pouring out of Kansas spooked the market. The traders who were short, had to buy contracts to close their short positions fuelling a very strong rally.

The rally can be seen in figure 1, which shows the spot market (and forwards) rising around 19¢/bu. The Kansas annual wheat tour also coincided with this week’s events, they performed a major croup tour stopping at 469 paddocks, and came up with a final yield estimate of 46.1 bushels per acre, which is below last year but above the five-year average. This announcement then caused the market to fall due to expectations that the weather events had largely caused little impact.

I would like to point out a few issues with the methodology used in this year’s crop update. Due to the snow event, the crop tour scouts were unable to perform any yield assessments. This therefore meant that the number of fields assessed reduced from 655 to 469 this year.

This yield estimate is therefore based on the fields with the smallest impact by recent weather, and yield/hectare losses will most likely be revised in the coming ten days. This may cause another short rally when the snow-covered fields are estimated, but likely the damage will not be as bad as previously expected.

At a local level (figure 2) we can see that prices have risen during the last week by around $5-10 dependent upon port zone. The local rise has seen the West receive most of the rise in futures, however other port zones have not seen the full rise. The basis levels also received a small rise (figure 3), but a rise which must be tempered by the fact that the previous week had seen a sharp fall in all port zones.

 

What does this mean?

We need to keep a very close eye on the market as it may present selling opportunities over the 1-2 weeks, if (as I expect) the Kansas crop is re-estimated to take into account the snow-covered fields. This may potentially result in speculators with short positions being spooked again. The commitment of trader’s report for this week will be of interest as it will give an indication of whether the funds are still bearish on agricultural commodities or has this week made them reassess.

On Saturday morning (Aus time) the US non-farm payrolls will be released and if the we see the US economy recovering and the likelihood of further rate rises we could see further pressure on the A$. Furthermore, Thursday morning (Aus time) the USDA WASDE report will be released giving us another insight into the supply and demand fundamentals.